Cost of Metal Roof vs Shingle: Which Is Better?
The cost of metal roof vs shingle is one of the biggest deciding factors for homeowners weighing their roofing options. Both materials offer unique benefits, but they come at different price points and long-term value. In North Dakota, where harsh winters, high winds, and extreme temperature shifts are common, choosing the right roofing material can make a big impact on your budget, comfort, and curb appeal.
- Upfront cost differences: Metal roofing is more expensive to install than asphalt shingles.
- Durability and longevity: Metal lasts longer but may require a higher initial investment.
- Climate performance: North Dakota’s weather makes material choice even more important.
Let’s break down the real costs, benefits, and considerations of each option so you can decide what’s best for your home.
Average Roof Costs in North Dakota
Roof replacement costs can vary significantly depending on the size and complexity of your roof. However, local averages give a solid baseline for comparison.
Metal Roofing Costs
Metal roofs are known for durability and longevity—but they come at a premium price.
- Average cost per square foot: $9–$14 installed
- Average total cost for a 2,000 sq. ft roof: $18,000–$28,000
- Lifespan: 40–70 years
- Warranty: Often 30–50 years
Standing seam and high-end steel roofing options may exceed this range, especially with complex rooflines.
Asphalt Shingle Roofing Costs
Asphalt shingles remain the most popular and affordable roofing option in North Dakota.
- Average cost per square foot: $4–$7 installed
- Average total cost for a 2,000 sq. ft roof: $8,000–$14,000
- Lifespan: 15–30 years
- Warranty: Typically 20–30 years
Architectural shingles fall on the higher end of this range, while basic 3-tab shingles are on the lower end.
Durability and Weather Resistance
North Dakota homeowners face a range of weather extremes—from heavy snowfall to hailstorms and summer heat. Choosing a roofing material that holds up to these conditions is essential.
Metal Roof Performance
Metal roofs are excellent at shedding snow and resisting wind damage, making them ideal for areas with strong winter storms like Valley City and surrounding areas.
- Snow shedding: Smooth surfaces and standing seams help prevent ice dams.
- Wind resistance: Many metal panels are rated for 120+ mph winds.
- Hail durability: Thicker gauge metal can withstand denting.
Shingle Roof Performance
Shingles can also handle North Dakota weather, but they are more vulnerable to certain conditions.
- Snow accumulation: Shingles may allow more snow and ice buildup.
- Wind damage: High winds can lift or tear off shingles if not properly installed.
- Hail impact: Shingles may crack or lose granules after storms.
Longevity and Maintenance
Long-term durability should be part of the cost equation. The longer your roof lasts, the more value you get from your investment.
Metal Roof Lifespan
With proper installation and minimal maintenance, a metal roof can last 40 to 70 years or more. Occasional inspections and touch-ups to the finish are usually all that’s needed.
Shingle Roof Lifespan
Shingle roofs typically need replacement every 15 to 30 years. Maintenance may include replacing damaged shingles, resealing flashing, or patching leaks.
Energy Efficiency and Savings
Metal and shingle roofs also differ in how they affect your home’s energy performance.
Metal Roof Energy Performance
Metal roofing reflects sunlight, keeping your attic cooler in the summer. Some systems can be installed with an insulating underlayment for additional energy efficiency.
- Energy savings: May reduce cooling costs by 10–15% in summer months.
- Solar compatibility: Great base for solar panel installation.
Shingle Roof Energy Performance
Shingles absorb more heat, which can increase attic temperatures in summer. However, modern shingle options with reflective granules can help improve performance.
- Cool roof shingles: Available, but typically cost more.
- Insulation reliance: Performance depends more heavily on attic insulation.
Appearance and Curb Appeal
Your roof plays a big role in your home’s visual style. Both metal and shingles offer a range of options.
Metal Roof Styles
- Standing seam: Sleek and modern look
- Metal shingles: Mimic slate, tile, or wood
- Colors: Available in dozens of shades and finishes
Shingle Roof Styles
- 3-tab shingles: Traditional and affordable
- Architectural shingles: Thicker and more dimensional
- Color options: Wide selection, often with textured surfaces
6 Questions to Ask Before Choosing Metal or Shingle
Here are six essential questions to consider before deciding which roofing material is right for your home:
- How long do you plan to live in your home?: If you’re staying for decades, metal’s long-term value may outweigh its higher cost. If you plan to move in 5–10 years, shingles may be more budget-friendly.
- What’s your upfront budget?: Shingles typically cost about half as much as metal roofing, making them easier to fit into tight budgets.
- Do you want to boost resale value?: Metal roofs may appeal to buyers looking for low maintenance and energy efficiency.
- How steep or complex is your roof?: Steep or intricate rooflines may increase installation costs—especially for metal.
- Are you concerned about noise?: Metal roofs can be noisier during rain or hail, but proper attic insulation usually solves the problem.
- Will you install solar panels?: If solar is part of your future, a standing seam metal roof may be the best long-term platform.
Which Roofing Option Is Right for You?
When comparing the cost of metal roof vs shingle, it’s clear that each has pros and cons. Metal roofing demands a higher upfront investment but delivers superior longevity, energy efficiency, and storm resistance—qualities that suit homes in Valley City and surrounding areas. Shingles, on the other hand, offer solid performance at a lower cost, making them ideal for budget-conscious homeowners or shorter-term stays.
At 5 Star Roofing and Contracting, we help homeowners across North Dakota choose the roofing solution that best fits their needs and budget. Whether you’re leaning toward metal or shingle, our experts can provide a free inspection, honest guidance, and flawless installation.
Contact 5 Star Roofing and Contracting today to schedule your free inspection and find the right roofing system for your home.
